Nature Shock Series Premiere: The Whale That Ate the Great White

Wednesday 14th October 8.00pm

The documentary series examining freak occurrences in the natural world returns. The first instalment of the new run explores a remarkable clash between two oceanic predators. In 1997, stunned tourists on a whale-watching trip off the coast of California witnessed an orca seemingly attack, kill and eat a great white shark – a unique event that gave scientists a radical new perspective on the habits of both species.

Located 27 miles west of San Francisco in the North Pacific, the Farallones are a small group of barren islands that play host to one of the world’s greatest concentrations of great white sharks. Every autumn, the predators flock to the area to feed on the seals that gather on the rocks. Since 1987, scientists based on the islands have been studying the sharks and have built a detailed picture of their behaviour. On 4 October 1997, however, one extraordinary event altered the scientists’ entire perspective.

Marine biologist Peter Pyle was working on the islands when reports came in of a shark attack with a difference. A group of tourists on board whale-watching boat the Superfish had witnessed an orca – very rarely seen near the Farallones – apparently attack a great white. Pyle raced to the scene. “As we approached, you could see the killer whale with a shark in its mouth,” he recalls.

Pyle’s colleague Mary Jane Schramm was on board the Superfish and saw the event unfold. “We were extremely excited,” she says. “It was a very big shark.” Schramm and the tourists were watching two orcas frolic in the waves when the shark appeared. It approached the boat, then swam away – at which point one of the orcas sped towards it. Both animals then disappeared, only for the orca to emerge minutes later with the half-ton shark held upside down in its mouth. “It was like a cat with a mouse,” says Mick Menigoz, skipper of the Superfish. “This was a once-in-a-lifetime thing.”

In the immediate aftermath of the attack, Pyle used a pole camera to record the orcas underwater. The mammals had now torn the shark apart and proceeded to eat parts of it, including the liver. After 15 minutes, they left the area. “It was a complete surprise for us,” says Pyle. “We had no idea that could happen.” While it was clear that an orca had killed and eaten a great white, what was not clear was how the former had overpowered the shark without a struggle. Then within days, an even bigger question arose. After the attack, the entire great white population – up to 100 individuals – suddenly disappeared. What had triggered the departure and where did the sharks go?

With the help of footage of the incident recorded by the tourists, marine biologists surmised that the orca rammed the great white to stun it, then held it upside down to immobilise it. Scientists in the Bahamas have discovered that sharks can be induced into a trance-like state by turning them onto their backs – a condition known as ‘tonic immobility’. Apparently, certain groups of orca have made the same discovery. “Orca are very smart,” says expert Ingrid Visser. “I’m pretty sure that tonic immobility is part of the repertoire of the orca.” Having observed the whales off the coast of New Zealand for many years, Visser thinks it feasible that they could habitually target great whites as food.

As to why the sharks fled after the attack, New Jersey scientist Craig O’Connell believes it was because of the “smell of death” in the water. Tests with lemon sharks show that chemicals released when a shark is killed trigger a violent flight reaction in others of the same species. While this might explain the initial dispersal, however, it does not explain why the great whites would stay away from the Farallones for the rest of the feeding season – especially when later research proved that some of them travel up to 4,000km to be there every autumn.

The bizarre incident at the Farallon Islands still holds some mysteries, but it has shed light on the hierarchy amongst the ocean’s most fearsome killers. “In my mind it’s really clear –we have a top predator here,” says marine biologist Alisa Schulman-Janiger of the orca.

About the author

  • lolly

    that is amazing and im feeling horny (i’m a girl)

  • ashling

    yeah i watched the show and i was amazed that a killer whale would take on a great white. the brain of an orca must be very complex if it understands tonic immobility. i wonder if orcas kill great whites all over the world and that the decrease in the great white population is not just down to humans? there could be a many killer whale pods who feed especially on the great white? and i am fascinated by ‘the smell of death’ and i wonder if in the beaches which are prone to shark attacks this chemical could be introduced to make it safer for sufers and those who participate in extreme sports.
    this is amazing to me and has inspired me to consider a career in marine biology.

  • Amy

    i loved this show. Lolly that is kind of creepy but whatever floats your boat…
    Its so strange how these animals are learning to adapt as the population in a lot of animals is going down. And now the Orca has probably become more dangerous than the great white to man kind. If killer whales can work out how to use tonic immobility as a hunting mechanism, god knows what else they’ll learn to start hunting surfers!!

  • frg

    to ashling:
    you don’t like the type of person who wishes to study marine biology for the sake of the animals, judging by your statement ‘this chemical could be introduced to make it safer for surfers and those who participate in extreme sports’.
    if your primary concern was for animals you would not condone disturbing their natural way of life, and possibly deterring them from an area which they use for foraging and possible other functions, and promote human invasion of the waters.
    if you felt strongly about marine biology you would wish to keep their homes safe for them, even if its just to ensure their is something left to study in years to come.

    with regards to the program, i feel it is about time people began to recognise how intelligent other animals are. animals are constantly evolving, and new amazing things are going to occur time and time again. i just wish it would be enough to deter people from the horrors of such things as poaching.

  • frg

    *you don’t seem like

  • Ben

    Ashling: I just watched this show and thought it was very good, incredibly interesting and well researched. However, the Orca’s brain does not need to be complex to understand tonic immobility. It doesn’t need to understand it, all it needs to do is accidentally flip a shark over once and get a good feed with no damage and positive reinforcement will do the rest of the job.

    The other Orcas simply need to imitate, although of course imitation is in itself a complex set of behaviours, an ability they already have. Once the two marry up, bingo.

  • kirstie

    i watched the show and i was amazed at the fact that a orca killed a great white wich is like 2 times the size of the orca, seeing the footage made me reaklise how intelegent orca’s are and that they can basicaly kill anything in the ocean

  • nixon

    Ben youve said “It doesn’t need to understand it, all it needs to do is accidentally flip a shark over”

    thats not true, as for one sharks do go upside down by themselves, they need to be held upside down for the tonic trance. so the orca would need to learn this as they have with sting rays. as show in the show orcas go upside down and then pick up the rays, so when they return to normal stance the rays are upside down and hense immobilised… so stating an orca would only need to knock it upside down is wrong, there clearly smarter than that. (well they are dolphins after all)


  • BBC One
  • BBC Two
  • BBC Three
  • ITV1
  • ITV2
  • 4
  • E4
  • Film4
  • More4
  • Five
  • Fiver
  • Sky1